Wednesday, November 04, 2009

Christian Chirp? Seriously?

I'm a generally conservative, evangelical Christian, but I'm at a loss to explain exactly why I bristle at the thought of a social media site called "Christian Chirp."  The following is an attempt to do so, and is my own personal opinion.  Please note that my opinions do not reflect the views of evangelical Christianity, the churches I serve and attend, or anybody or anything else.  You can comment if you like, but if I don't like your comment, it won't get published.  It's my blog, get over it.

So - what's wrong with "Christian Chirp?"

1) Christian Chirp.  That has got to be the lamest name ever.  However, I know people who actually think that sort of stuff is cool.  Or hip.  Or now, or...whatever - wake up!  It's lame, people.  And to anyone even considering making the irrelevant appeal "but what about the name Twitter?" - save it, it's irrelevant. I think the name is lame, so there.  You can think what you like.

2) It was formed because the founder felt he was being persecuted on Twitter because of his conservative beliefs.  And he's very vocal about it, too.  The truth is his Twitter account was suspended for a week for sending a large number of duplicate @replies - the fact that the offending message was about Rush Limbaugh is purely coincidental.  When you send the same message out too many times, that is considered spammer behavior, and they suspend your account pending investigation.  It's all very clearly spelled out in Twitter's Terms of Use, where it says: "Some of the factors that we take into account when determining what conduct is considered to be spamming are: .....If you send large numbers of duplicate @replies."  I'm still waiting for this guy to man up and admit he blew it instead of continuing to play the persecution card.

3) The founder also runs two other sites - ChristianInternetIncome.com and Christian Money.com.  This isn't a secret, both websites are listed right on his profile.  Forgive me for assuming, but it appears he's successfully created his own lead generation service, kudos for his ingenuity.  Not that there's anything wrong with making money, but using the term "Christian" as a selling point is kinda lame.  Wow, I used the word "lame" twice!  The founder of Christian Chirp isn't alone here, I have a problem with any business opportunity that markets itself as Christian, for Christians.

4) The whole idea of Christians holing up in their own little world rather defeats the purpose of the great commission, don't you think?  I mean, sure, we worship together and we have classes and other opportunities to be together as believers - why do we need our own social media outlet, too?  Seems silly to me.  Think about what happened to all those Virb users who were so excited about Virb two years ago - well, I'm guessing they all signed up, and a month later looked around and noticed nobody else was signing up. They're all on Facebook now.  And Twitter.  I wonder if they'll try Christian Chirp?  Probably.  I digress...

5) Are there seriously Christians out there who don't have non-Christian friends, who don't read non-Christian publications and have no interest in anything other than Christian this and Christian that?  Seriously?  Christian Chirp is like a club you have to belong to in order to socialize.  LAME!!!  (3 times) Somebody used the term "Christian Ghetto" - and while I didn't appreciate the derogatory sound of that, I realized the term was rather fitting in an effort to describe the segregated culture Christian Chirp potentially creates.

These are just my hastily thought out observations and opinions at the moment.  As a woman, I reserve the right to change my mind tomorrow, but that's it for today.

Check it out for yourself.  What do you think?

13 comments:

Nora said...

You're right. About everything. ESPECIALLY the it's-your-blog-so-get-over-it part. I think Christian Chirp sounds like just another way for Christians to cloister themselves away from the rest of the world and avoid dialogue. I can appreciate the desire to connect with other Christians for a variety of reasons, but it isn't like there aren't plenty of discussion boards/Facebook groups/Christian dating sites/actual-real-live-ways-to-communicate-with-other-Christians out there. Plus I worry that defining something like this as "for Christians only" could get really divisive if someone were to take a theological or political stance that one person or another deems "more Christian" than another view.

Kim said...

This guy is a legend in his own mind - enjoy his podcast about all the persecution he's been enduring. Good grief. http://www.talkshoe.com/talkshoe/web/audioPop.jsp?episodeId=288584&cmd=apop

Kim said...

Another thing that bugs me is that the terms "Christian" and "Conservative" are used almost interchangeably.

Dan said...

Somewhere on "Stuff Christians Like" there ought to be a listing for "creating cheezy knock-offs of stuff everybody else likes, only cleaner and more wholesome!" To me, there are two sides of the issue. The darker side is the marketers who play to this mass to make a quick buck (i.e. publishers of Christian romance novels and Left Behind books), and the sadder side of so many Christians who drink the kool-aid and think this is actually the mark of a True Disciple, living in the sanitized bubble of Christian copycats.

Kim said...

It's only a matter of time before it shows up on Stuff Christians Like. I'm also waiting for MMI to open up a discussion.

I've been struggling with the thought that maybe I've just gotten too cynical in my old age. But I can't get past the fact that I have a serious aversion to cheesiness, the prosperity gospel, and big mouths with an ax to grind. Shudder...

Matt Nightingale said...

I'm with you, Kim. 100%

Kim said...

Thanks, Matt. :)

Anonymous said...

hope you dont mind, but i tweeted this blog. i WAS intending to blog about this myself, but you took the words right outta my mouth and said everything i was thinking!!!

Karen said...

For someone who claims to be a Christian, listing your "astrological sign" is contradictory.

Kim said...

That comment from Karen was so funny I had to publish it. #1 - I have no idea who this person is, and they've made their Blogger profile private. #2- What is this person's motivation for publishing such an off-the-wall comment completely unrelated to the subject matter, and #3 - Dear, dear Karen - Blogger automatically lists astrological signs if you want your birthday published on your profile, something which, sadly, I have no control over.

This has been a public service announcement. We now return you to your regularly scheduled program, already in progress.

Kim said...

Hey everyone! Good news! I hadn't edited my profile in so long, I never noticed that they have a box you can check or uncheck regarding your astrological sign! Happy to uncheck it - wow, thanks Karen, if you hadn't stopped by, who knows how much longer it would have been before I discovered that feature. Thanks! :)

OK, commercial break really over now...

Danny Clayton said...

Bravo. Especially the point about other friends who might not be believers--and that we might not read publications that are 'Christian' in nature. We have to get in and mix it up with everyone--isn't that what drove the Pharisees nuts about Jesus? He had friends in low places.

Kim said...

Thanks, Danny. I'm beginning to suspect that CC's main function is a Christian Internet Marketing lead generation service. It doesn't seem to offer much else right now. Trouble is, most of the people signed up there are internet marketers and those trying to promote their online businesses...are they all just going to try to prospect and sell each other? LOL